Passing Notes

Question: The end of the novel is ambiguous, leaving open the possibility that Irene has pushed Clare out the window or that Clare has killed herself.  Which possibility do you defend? Why?

I. Student Impressions

-- “Very Interesting”

-- “Did not like it”

-- “Too descriptive in the beginning” (the Chicago weather and pavement scene)

-- “The grammar was not very well done” – but it is a dialect

-- “It was like Spinning Into Butter—it was a bit too much for me (the first chapter was bunk)”

-- The set up came on pages 147 and 148 (back in Chicago)

-- “I absolutely hate this book.  It was a literal chore to go from page to page.  It promotes racism.”

 

II. Important page numbers

-- 146  

-- 147-148

-- 177 “longing” hmmm…

 

III. Themes
1. Passing Black for white / white for black
2.
An affair?
3. The 1920s (the roaring 20s) before prohibition. 

 

IV. The Women (The ladies are different from one another in what ways?)

1. Clare
A. Clare and Brian??? Why do you think this?
-- Clare was outgoing
-- Clare was beautiful
-- She was good at convincing people to see things her way
-- She gets what she wants
-- Irene was insecure (she used to be able to look at her husband and change his mood.  Not so much lately)
-- Brian invites Clare to a party and Irene gets upset
-- Irene seems jealous of Clare (maybe not an affair)
-- Irene saw Clare with a man other than her husband
-- Brian offered to drive Clare home yet he dropped his wife at the house first

B. Clare and John Bellew
-- daughter Margery

 

2. Irene and Brian Redfield
-- sons Brian Junior and Theodore
-- Irene has trouble saying no.