RESEARCH QUESTION: What causes stuttering in
children?
Irwin,
Ann. “Successful Treatment of Stuttering.”
Time 12 Apr. 2006. Academic
Search Premier. Ebsco Publishing. Manatee
Community Coll. Lib., Bradenton. 3 Sept.
2006. http://www.Epnet.com.
In
this article on stuttering, psychologist Ann Irwin explains that parental
reactions play an important role in creating stuttering as learned behavior.
In her article, “Successful Treatment Stuttering,” she claims that parents,
although they are "trying to do what is best" for their children,
are often the "accidental cause" of this speech disorder. Based on her own work and studies conducted by
speech therapists at the University of Pennsylvania, she recounts that parents
play a key role in this speech impediment. When parents see something in their
child's speech which is "not quite the same as before," they "quite
naturally" begin to correct it, explains Irwin. This, she adds, is the
beginning of "trouble." Irwin describes a five-year-old child who repeated
a word's initial syllable thirty-five times without realizing anything was
wrong. The danger, she argues, is in
"making an issue of a child's repetitions and prolongations," a
pattern which will make the child "self-conscious" and which can
"aggravate" the child's speech problems. if parents knew that the trouble is not so much
in the “first signs of tension” in some of the words the child speaks, but
in the “correcting” of it," she concludes, "they would probably
have a child who does not stutter instead of one who does.” This article contains
critical information for my third sub-point—that parents are the cause of
stuttering.